The Morning: Mass shooting in Buffalo

May 15, 2022

By The New York Times

Good morning. A massacre at a Buffalo supermarket was the deadliest in the U.S. this year.

The Tops supermarket in Buffalo.Joshua Bessex/Associated Press

Bodies 'everywhere'

A gunman embracing a white supremacist ideology opened fire yesterday afternoon at a supermarket in a predominantly Black neighborhood of Buffalo, killing 10 people and wounding three more. The mass shooting was the deadliest in the United States this year and among a spate of racist attacks in recent years.

The suspect, Payton S. Gendron, 18, had driven more than 200 miles to stage the attack, and he livestreamed it as he fired at shoppers and store employees. He was arrested at the store and pleaded not guilty in a brief court appearance.

Around the same time, a manifesto attributed to him appeared online, repeatedly invoking the racist idea that white Americans were at risk of being replaced by people of color. The view is known as "replacement theory" and was once linked to the far-right fringe, but it has become increasingly mainstream.

Among the victims were a security guard and an 86-year-old mother of four who had stopped at the store on her way home from visiting her husband at the nursing home where he lives.

How the shooting unfolded

Around 2:30 p.m., as shoppers filled the Tops supermarket, the suspect arrived wearing body armor, tactical gear and a helmet with a video camera attached. He carried an assault rifle with an anti-Black slur written on the barrel and began firing in the parking lot. Three victims were killed outside, and one was wounded.

Then the suspect went inside the store to continue his attack, briefly exchanging fire with the security guard before killing him. He went on to stalk victims throughout the store; "bodies were everywhere," one witness said.

Shonnell Harris, a store manager, told The Buffalo News that she heard an estimated 70 shots and ran through the Tops, repeatedly falling down before escaping out back.

The gunman eventually returned to the front of the store. By then, the police had arrived, and he briefly put a gun to his neck before he began removing tactical gear as a form of surrender and the police tackled him.

Residents prayed near the store.Malik Rainey for The New York Times

The victims

Of the 13 people who were shot, 11 were Black and two were white. Four worked at the Tops grocery. Few have been publicly identified.

The security guard who was killed was a former police officer — "a hero in our eyes," said Joseph A. Gramaglia, the Buffalo police commissioner.

Ruth Whitfield, 86, was a mother of four and "a mother to the motherless," her son told The News. Her husband had moved into a nursing home years ago and she still visited every day. She had just visited him when she stopped at Tops to get something to eat, WGRZ reported.

The suspect

The attack appeared to be inspired by earlier mass shootings motivated by racial hatred, including a 2019 mosque shooting in New Zealand and a massacre at a Texas Walmart that same year, according to the manifesto.

In chilling detail, the document outlined a plan to kill as many Black people as possible, including the type of gun to use, a timeline, a specific parking spot and where to eat ahead of time.

Gendron wrote that he chose the area of the supermarket because it was home to the largest percentage of Black residents near his home in New York's largely white Southern Tier. The police had surrounded his home outside Binghamton, N.Y., overnight.

"It was a straight up racially motivated hate crime," said John Garcia, the local sheriff.

Federal law enforcement officials said they were investigating the shooting as a hate crime. The next court proceeding was set for Thursday.

For More

What we know about how the shooting happened.
"This is our store": Witnesses described the scene.
Churches in Buffalo planned prayer services today.
At least 17 people were wounded in a shooting in Milwaukee.
Follow our updates.

NEWS

The Virus

The New York Times devoted its front page today to the American death toll from Covid.

This is how the U.S. lost one million people.
Many of the Covid victims' loved ones are grieving in a nation that wants to move on.

The Ukraine War

NATO is on the brink of its largest expansion in two decades. Russia lashed out in response.
Mitch McConnell and other Senate Republicans made an unannounced visit to Ukraine.
Germans are divided about whether the authorities should go after wealthy Russians' villas around an Alpine lake.

FROM OPINION

Amy Coney Barrett once said justices should not "impose their will on the world." Now she is doing just that, Maureen Dowd writes.
A long-term Ukraine strategy that requires bipartisan U.S. support might be unwise, Ross Douthat writes.
Dr. Oz's Senate run is testing the political value of celebrity, Michelle Cottle writes.
Let actors play roles outside their real-life identities, Pamela Paul argues.

The Sunday question: Are high prices here to stay?

Supply-chain issues and consumer demand for goods seem to be easing, says Bloomberg Opinion's Conor Sen, and interest-rate hikes will help slow inflation. But Harvard's Jason Furman notes that price increases are spreading to services like restaurant dining and could stay high for a while.

Deeply reported journalism needs your support.

The Times relies on subscribers to help fund our mission. Subscribe now with this special offer.

MORNING READS

Jane Lynch, center, with fans.Natalie Keyssar for The New York Times

Sunday Routine: The actress Jane Lynch loves strolls in Central Park and spicy salmon rolls.

Hottest ticket: N.Y.U.'s latest honorary grad? Taylor Swift.

Thriving underground: Tattoos are outlawed in South Korea, but they're in fashion.

A Times classic: You don't need a recipe.

Advice from Wirecutter: Don't use too much dish soap.

BOOKS

Rebecca Clarke

By the Book: The next book on Selma Blair's list is "Stoner," recommended by Jamie Lee Curtis.

Our editors' picks: "Trust," by Hernan Diaz, is an exhilarating novel that explores the unchecked rise of a financier in the early 20th century, and 11 other books.

Times best sellers: Catherine Belton's "Putin's People" and Walter Isaacson's "The Code Breaker" are paperback nonfiction best-sellers. See all our lists here.

The Book Review podcast: John Waters discusses his first novel.

THE SUNDAY TIMES MAGAZINE

Catera Northup had liposuction and a Brazilian butt lift.Naila Ruechel for The New York Times

It's the magazine's health issue, all about body modifications. Brazilian butt lifts are everywhere. But the recovery process is extremely painful, as documented in this photo essay.

Learn more about phalloplasty — a complex and controversial surgery to make a penis, which is popular with trans men. Can cosmetic surgery be a feminist act? And read one man's account of using a dieting app. Beyond the body, meet the man who controls computers with his mind.

Read the full issue.

THE WEEK AHEAD

What to Watch For

Sweden is expected to announce its decision to apply for NATO membership today.
Congress is expected to pass a $40 billion aid package for Ukraine this week.
Idaho, Kentucky, North Carolina, Pennsylvania and Oregon will hold primary elections on Tuesday.
On Tuesday, the House intelligence committee will hold the first public hearing on U.F.O.s in more than half a century.
President Biden will travel to Japan and South Korea at the end of the week.
A neutral expert is set to present new congressional maps for New York this week, after Democrats' maps were thrown out in court.
Australia will hold elections on Saturday. Polls suggest Prime Minister Scott Morrison's party is likely to lose power.
The Cannes Film Festival begins this week. "Top Gun: Maverick" will premiere 36 years after the original. Here's what else is playing.
The year's first total lunar eclipse will make the moon appear red for much of the U.S. tonight.

What to Cook This Week

Sang An for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Simon Andrews. Prop Stylist: Paige Hicks.

Eggs aren't just for breakfast, or weekends, as Emily Weinstein notes. A few options for dinner: huevos rancheros, plantains with jammy tomatoes and eggs or pasta with mushrooms, fried eggs and herbs.

NOW TIME TO PLAY

Andrew Dore

Here's a clue from the Sunday crossword:

5 Down: Character seen on a keyboard.

Take the news quiz to see how well you followed this week's headlines.

Here's today's Wordle. Here's today's Spelling Bee. If you're in the mood to play more, find all our games here.

Thanks for spending part of your weekend with The Times.

Claire Moses, Ian Prasad Philbrick, Tom Wright-Piersanti, Ashley Wu and Sanam Yar contributed to The Morning. You can reach the team at themorning@nytimes.com.