The messy magic of Moonlighting

For years, Moonlighting, the late-'80s detective/romcom starring Bruce Willis and Cybill Shepherd, has been on a lot of people's lists of shows that weren't on streaming and should be on streaming. Well, now it's on streaming. Specifically, it's on Hulu. All five seasons are there, from the splashy TV movie that served as the pilot to the fourth and fifth rounds when the show was huffing and puffing and rarely delivering the way it did in the beginning. (Sometimes people say this is because they "got together" as a couple and it ruined the show; this is factually incorrect.)

But oh, those first three seasons. Even back in the 1980s, when network television is often too-simply remembered as having been formulaic and desperately in need of the reinvention cable would bring, Moonlighting was sharp and strange and experimental.

Cybill Shepherd and Bruce Willis in Moonlighting. Hulu

One reason was the stars. It's immediately obvious why this show shot Bruce Willis, probably then best known as the guy who sang in a commercial for Seagrams wine coolers -- speaking of the 1980s -- directly to superstar status. He plays David Addison as cocky but insecure, his fast-talking slickness both a method of survival and a lubricant that lets him slide through life without working too hard. Cybill Shepherd plays Maddie Hayes, a wealthy and cool-toned former model (like Shepherd herself) who is scammed out of all her money and discovers that she's the owner of a ragtag detective agency that was being maintained as a tax writeoff. And so, Maddie and David become partners.

On the surface, it's such a classic pairing that it borders on cliché: He's a vulgar and wisecracking man-child, she's a classy tough broad horrified by his shenanigans. But it turns out that he is quite soft-hearted, and that she is whip-smart and fearless, and this part, you and I have both heard before.

But the execution, led by creator Glenn Gordon Caron, took an unfamiliar shape. The most obvious precursors to this show were probably Hart to Hart, about a glamorous married couple who solve crimes, and Remington Steele, which is about a woman who invents a fake male partner to lend her detective agency credibility. (The latter, by the way, did for Pierce Brosnan what Moonlighting did for Bruce Willis.) The difference is that both of those, while certainly wryly funny, had a tone that remained largely tethered to reality.

Moonlighting, on the other hand, went fully farcical, particularly late in each episode when the climactic action sequences came along. They include four identically dressed people running through a hotel to the William Tell Overture, a pie-throwing scene, and a chase in a hearse where the whole funeral procession gets involved. ("David, we're being followed. By a lot of people.") The dialogue was dense with jokes and wordplay; check out this rhyming sequence, which is thrown in with no explanation at all, and which is only funnier when you watch the bloopers of the poor actor in the scene with Shepherd and Willis trying to wrap his mouth around it.

And, too, there were the format-breakers. "The Dream Sequence Always Rings Twice," a black-and-white episode introduced by Orson Welles, was shot on real black-and-white film rather than being simply decolorized, and it's absolutely gorgeous to look at. The Shakespeare riff "Atomic Shakespeare" is playful and silly, but also clever. Stanley Donen (who directed Singin' in the Rain) even choreographed a dream ballet to a Billy Joel song for the episode "Big Man on Mulberry Street."

But for all the fast talk (this is the show that made me a fan of banter) and all the experimentation, and for all the production delays and rumored on-set drama, what surprises me when I look back at these episodes is how effectively Willis and Shepherd could turn on a dime and play true, touching, often very simple emotional scenes together that co-existed with that farce and that experimentation. They're both great in "Every Daughter's Father Is a Virgin," a deeply bittersweet episode about a visit from Maddie's parents, played by Robert Webber and Eva Marie Saint. They're both great in "Big Man on Mulberry Street," in which they deal with a previously un-discussed episode in David's past. And they're both great in "Witness for the Execution," which is about a difficult case they can't agree on (and which includes a milestone moment for their relationship).

Some things do not age well over a period of nearly 40 years; in particular, David's unabashed horniness is played for laughs even though it happens at work and amounts to sexual harassment of his boss/partner. But the pleasures of this show that burned very brightly and very chaotically remain well worth revisiting.

Newsletter continues after sponsor message

We Recommend

I cannot tell a lie -- The Golden Bachelor is more charming than I expected. Gerry, who's a 72-year-old widower, seems very genuine and more than a little dorky, and most of the women who want to date him appear nice and also genuine. While there is a lot of talk about finding love later in life, there aren't nearly as many "break a hip" or "early bird special" jokes as I was afraid there would be. We'll be covering it on the show in a bit, but honestly, I do sort of dig it.

The extremely popular novel Lessons in Chemistry is now an Apple TV+ series starring Brie Larson. The story of Elizabeth Zott, a scientist in the 1950s and '60s who becomes a cooking show host, has its ups and downs, but Larson is charming and the series is, for lack of a better word, sort of soothing.

My childhood baseball team was the Philadelphia Phillies, who, as you read this, are headed to the National League Championship Series against the Arizona Diamondbacks. If they win that series, they will face either the Houston Astros or the Texas Rangers in the World Series. The Phillies have had a hint of beer league about them in many eras -- their scraggly beards, their scraggly hair, what a friend of mine once insisted was an unmatched tendency to have tobacco juice on their shirts. All of this to say, Kelsey McKinney wrote a very funny and well-researched piece for Defector about their tendency to "show clavicle" with open shirts, and I commend it most highly to you. Go Phils!

Listen to the Podcast Sponsor-Free

Support your favorite pop culture junkies AND listen without sponsor interruptions with a subscription to Pop Culture Happy Hour+! Learn more and sign up at plus.npr.org/happy.

Learn More

What We Did This Week

Craig (Josh Sharp), God (Bowen Yang) and Trevor (Aaron Jackson) in Dicks: The Musical. Justin Lubin/A24

Glen and Aisha got spooky with Marc Rivers and Jordan Crucchiola to answer the question: What's the scariest movie you've ever seen?

Aisha and Glen also met up with Jeffrey Masters to talk about the colorfully named movie Dicks: The Musical. Glen also wrote a review! (I was writing this bit and suddenly thought, "I should mention that I've been watching the fully nude Max dating show Naked Attraction and that we'll be doing an episode on it shortly," so consider that a bonus recommendation.)

Glen talked to Jordan Crucchiola and Cristina Escobar about The Fall of the House of Usher, the latest Netflix adaptation of a spooky classic.

Aisha and I were joined by Wailin Wong and former PCHH producer/current ICYMI host Candice Lim to chat about the new film Fair Play, which really makes it seem like you should leave work at work.

What's Making Us Happy

Every week on the show, we talk about some other things out in the world that have been giving us joy lately. Here they are:

Wailin Wong: Two Set Violin
Candice Lim: "2 Die 4" by Addison Rae featuring Charli XCX
Linda Holmes: Moonlighting, now streaming on Hulu
Aisha Harris: The Royal Hotel, now in theaters

Stream your local NPR station.

Visit NPR.org to find your local station stream.

Subscribe to Pop Culture Happy Hour+. Your support helps make our show possible and unlocks access to our sponsor-free episodes.

What do you think of today's email? We'd love to hear your thoughts, questions and feedback: pchh@npr.org

Enjoying this newsletter? Forward to a friend! They can sign up here.

Looking for more great content? Check out all of our newsletter offerings — including Music, Books, Daily News and more!

You received this message because you're subscribed to Pop Culture Happy Hour emails. This email was sent by National Public Radio, Inc., 1111 North Capitol Street NE, Washington, DC 20002

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy